| 2020 |
| Growing Things and Other Stories , Paul Tremblay. |
| F | Exhalation [Exhalación] , Ted Chiang. |
| F | Lady Bits , Kate Jonez. |
| F | Out of Water , Sarah Read. |
| F | Sefira and Other Betrayals , John Langan. |
| 2019 |
| That Which Grows Wild , Eric J. Guignard. |
| F | Coyote Songs , Gabino Iglesias. |
| F | Dark and Distant Voices , Tim Waggoner. |
| F | Garden of Eldritch Delights , Lucy A. Snyder. |
| F | Spectral Evidence , Gemma Files. |
| 2018 |
| Strange Weather [Tiempo extraño] , Joe Hill. |
| F | And Her Smile Will Untether the Universe , Gwendolyn Kiste. |
| F | Goblin , Josh Malerman. |
| F | Writing Madness , Patrick McGrath, Harry Brockway & Danel Olson. |
| F | The Carp-Faced Boy and Other Tales , Thersa Matsuura. |
| 2017 |
| The Doll-Master and Other Tales of Terror , Joyce Carol Oates. |
| F | A Long December , Richard Chizmar. |
| F | American Nocturne , Hank Schwaeble. |
| F | Lethal Birds , Gene O'Neill. |
| F | Swift to Chase , Laird Barron. |
| 2016 |
| While the Black Stars Burn , Lucy A. Snyder. |
| F | Halfway Down the Stairs , Gary A. Braunbeck. |
| F | The Mirrors , Nicole Cushing. |
| F | The Dark at the End of the Tunnel , Taylor Grant. |
| F | The Hitchhiking Effect , Gene O'Neill. |
| 2015 |
| Soft Apocalypses , Lucy Snyder. |
| 2014 |
| The Beautiful Thing That Awaits Us All and Other Stories , Laird Barron. |
| 2013 |
| New Moon on the Water , Mort Castle. |
| Black Dahlia and White Rose: Stories , Joyce Carol Oates. |
| F | The Janus Tree and Other Stories , Glen Hirshberg. |
| F | Errantry , Elizabeth Hand. |
| F | Woman Who Married a Cloud: Collected Stories , Jonathan Carroll. |
| 2012 |
| The Corn Maiden and Other Nightmares , Joyce Carol Oates. |
| 2011 |
| Full Dark, No Stars [Todo oscuro, sin estrellas] , Stephen King. |
| F | A Host of Shadows , Harry Shannon. |
| F | Blood and Gristle , Michael Louis Calvillo. |
| F | Occultation , Laird Barron. |
| F | The Ones that Got Away , Stephen Graham Jones. |
| 2010 |
| Taste of Tenderloin , Gene O'Neill. |
| F | Got to Kill Them All and Other Stories , Dennis Etchison. |
| F | In the Closet, Under the Bed , Lee Thomas. |
| F | Martyrs and Monsters , Robert Dunbar. |
| 2009 |
| Just After Sunset [Después del anochecer] , Stephen King. |
| F | Mr. Gaunt and Other Uneasy Encounters , John Langan. |
| F | Mama's Boy and Other Dark Tales , Fran Friel. |
| F | Gleefully Macabre Tales , Jeff Strand. |
| F | The Number 121 to Pennsylvania , Kealan Patrick Burke. |
| 2008 |
| 5 Stories , Peter Straub. |
| Proverbs for Monsters , Michael A. Arnzen. |
| F | Defining Moments , David Niall Wilson. |
| F | The Imago Sequence and Other Stories , Laird Barron. |
| F | Old Devil Moon , Christopher Fowler. |
| 2007 |
| Destinations Unknown , Gary A. Braunbeck. |
| F | American Morons , Glen Hirshberg. |
| F | The Empire of Ice Cream , Jeffrey Ford. |
| F | Basic Black: Tales of Appropriate Fear , Terry Dowling. |
| F | The Commandments , Angeline Hawkes. |
| 2006 |
| 20th Century Ghosts [Fantasmas] , Joe Hill. |
| F | Magic for Beginners , Kelly Link. |
| F | Soldier of Sidon [Soldado de Sidón] , Gene Wolfe. |
| F | Haunted , Chuck Palahniuk. |
| 2005 |
| Fearful Symmetries , Thomas F. Monteleone. |
| F | 100 Jolts: Shockingly Short Stories , Michael Arnzen. |
| F | Demonized , Christopher Fowler. |
| F | Fears Unnamed , Tim Lebbon. |
| F | The Machinery of Night , Douglas Clegg. |
| 2004 |
| Peaceable Kingdom , Jack Ketchum. |
| F | Bibliomancy , Elizabeth Hand. |
| F | Fangs and Angel Wings , Karen E. Taylor. |
| F | Graveyard People: The Collected Cedar Hill Stories Vol 1 , Gary A. Braunbeck. |
| F | Told by the Dead , Ramsey Campbell. |
| 2003 |
| One More for the Road [Algo más que el equipaje] , Ray Bradbury. |
| F | Everything's Eventual [Todo es eventual] , Stephen King. |
| F | The Collection , Bentley Little. |
| F | Knuckles and Tales , Nancy A. Collins. |
| F | Nations of the Living, Nations of the Dead , Mort Castle. |
| 2002 |
| The Man with the Barbed-Wire Fists , Norman Partridge. |
| F | As the Sun Goes Down , Tim Lebbon. |
| F | The Dark Fantastic , Ed Gorman. |
| F | The Whisperer and Other Voices , Brian Lumley. |
| 2001 |
| Magic Terror: Seven Tales , Peter Straub. |
| F | City Fishing , Steve Rasnic Tem. |
| F | Up, Out of Cities That Blow Hot and Cold , Charlee Jacob. |
| F | Wind Over Heaven and Other Dark Tales , Bruce Holland Rogers. |
| 2000 |
| The Nightmare Chronicles , Douglas Clegg. |
| F | Hearts in Atlantis [Corazones en la Atlántida] , Stephen King. |
| F | Death Drives a Semi , Edo van Belkom. |
| F | Deep Into that Darkness Peering , Tom Piccirilli. |
| 1999 |
| Black Butterflies: A Flock on the Dark Side , John Shirley. |
| F | Smoke and Mirrors [Humo y espejos] , Neil Gaiman. |
| F | Leavings , P(atricia). D. Cacek. |
| F | The Cleft and other Odd Tales , Gahan Wilson, ed.. |
| 1998 |
| Exorcisms and Ecstasies , Karl Edward Wagner. |
| F | The Throne of Bones , Brian McNaughton. |
| F | Painted in Blood , Lucy Taylor. |
| F | Things Left Behind , Gary A. Braunbeck. |
| 1997 |
| The Nightmare Factory [La fábrica de pesadillas] , Thomas Ligotti. |
| F | The Pavilion of Frozen Women , S. P. Somtow. |
| F | The Convulsion Factory , Brian Hodge. |
| F | Shadow Dreams , Elizabeth Massie. |
| F | With Wounds Still Wet , Wayne Allen Sallee. |
| 1996 |
| The Panic Hand , Jonathan Carroll. |
| F | The Black Carousel , Charles L. Grant. |
| F | Cages , Ed Gorman. |
| F | Strange Highways , Dean R. Koontz. |
| 1995 |
| The Early Fears , Robert Bloch. |
| F | Born Bad , Andrew Vachss. |
| F | The Flesh Artist , Lucy Taylor. |
| F | Writer Of The Purple Rage , Joe R. Lansdale. |
| 1994 |
| Alone With the Horrors , Ramsey Campbell. |
| F | Lovedeath , Dan Simmons. |
| F | Close to the Bone , Lucy Taylor. |
| F | A Good and Secret Place , Richard Laymon. |
| F | Nightmares & Dreamscapes [Pesadillas y alucinaciones] , Stephen King. |
| 1993 |
| Mr. Fox and Other Feral Tales , Norman Partridge. |
| F | Fantastic Tales , I. U. Tarchetti. |
| F | Nightmare Flower , Elizabeth Engstrom. |
| 1992 |
| Prayers to Broken Stones , Dan Simmons. |
| F | Author's Choice Monthly Issue 24: The Naked Flesh of Feeling , J. N. Williamson. |
| F | Sexpunks & Savage Sagas , Richard Sutphin. |
| F | Waking Nightmares , Ramsey Campbell. |
| 1991 |
| Four Past Midnight [Después de medianoche] , Stephen King. |
| F | The Brains of Rats , Michael Blumlein. |
| F | Houses Without Doors [Casas sin puertas] , Peter Straub. |
| 1990 |
| Richard Matheson: Collected Stories [Nacido de hombre y mujer, y otros relatos espeluznantes...] , Richard Matheson. |
| F | Blue World and Other Stories [Mundo azul] , Robert R. McCammon. |
| F | Patterns [Matrices] , Pat Cadigan. |
| F | By Bizarre Hands: Stories , Joe R. Lansdale. |
| F | Soft and Others , F. Paul Wilson. |
| 1989 |
| Charles Beaumont: Selected Stories , Charles Beaumont. |
| 1988 |
| The Essential Ellison: A 35-Year Retrospective , Harlan Ellison. |
