| 2020 | 2019 | 2018 | 2017 | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 |
| Novel |
| Coyote Rage , Owl Goingback. |
| F | Inspection , Josh Malerman. |
| F | Into the Ashes , Lee Murray. |
| F | The Worst is Yet to Come , S. P. Miskowski. |
| F | Wanderers , Chuck Wendig. |
| Long Fiction |
| Up from Slavery , Victor LaValle. |
| F | Into Bones Like Oil , Kaaron Warren. |
| F | The Cat Sitter , Anna Taborska. |
| F | The Keeper of Chernobyl , Alessandro Manzetti. |
| F | To Be Devoured , Sara Tantlinger. |
| Short Fiction |
| The Eight People Who Murdered Me (Excerpt from Lucy Westenra's Diary) , Gwendolyn Kiste. |
| F | A Touch of Madness , Tim Waggoner. |
| F | Bury Me in Tar and Twine , Jess Landry. |
| F | Lydia , Cindy O'Quinn. |
| F | The Book of Last Words , Greg Chapman. |
| Anthology |
| Echoes: The Saga Anthology of Ghost Stories , Ellen Datlow, ed.. |
| F | A Secret Guide to Fighting Elder Gods , Jennifer Brozek, ed.. |
| F | Nox Pareidolia , Robert S. Wilson. |
| F | Pop the Clutch: Thrilling Tales of Rockabilly, Monsters, and Hot Rod Horror , Eric J. Guignard, ed.. |
| F | The Twisted Book of Shadows , Christopher Golden & James A. Moore, eds.. |
| Collection |
| Growing Things and Other Stories , Paul Tremblay. |
| F | Exhalation [Exhalación] , Ted Chiang. |
| F | Lady Bits , Kate Jonez. |
| F | Out of Water , Sarah Read. |
| F | Sefira and Other Betrayals , John Langan. |
| First Novel |
| The Bone Weaver's Orchard , Sarah Read. |
| F | Dear Laura , Gemma Amor. |
| F | Doorways to the Deadeye , Eric J. Guignard. |
| F | Invisible Chains , Michelle Renee Lane. |
| F | The Luminous Dead , Caitlin Starling. |
| Young Adult Novel |
| Oware Mosaic , Nzondi. |
| F | Eight Minutes, Thirty-Two Seconds , Peter Adam Salomon. |
| F | Five Midnights , Ann Dávila Cardinal. |
| F | Here There Are Monsters , Amelinda Bérubé. |
| F | Rules for Vanishing , Kate Alice Marshall. |
| F | Speak No Evil , Liana Gardner. |
| Non Fiction |
| Monster, She Wrote: The Women Who Pioneered Horror and Speculative Fiction , Lisa Kröger & Melanie R. Anderson. |
| F | Gender, Sexuality, and Queerness in American Horror Story: Critical Essays , Harriet E. H. Earle, ed.. |
| F | Horror and Religion: New Literary Approaches to Theology, Race, and Sexuality , Eleanor Beal & Jonathan Greenaway, eds.. |
| F | Masks in Horror Cinema: Eyes Without Faces , Alexandra Heller-Nicholas. |
| F | Shapeshifters: A History , John B. Kachuba. |
| Short Non-Fiction |
| Magic, Madness, and Women Who Creep: The Power of Individuality in the Work of Charlotte Perkins Gilman , Gwendolyn Kiste. |
| F | Film's First Lycanthrope: 1913's The Werewolf , Kelly Robinson. |
| F | Lord Byron's Whipping Boy: Dr. John William Polidori and the 200th Anniversary of The Vampyre , Valerie E. Weich. |
| F | Slasher Films Made Me Gay: The Queer Appeal and Subtext of the Genre , Vince A. Liaguno. |
| F | The Evil Aging Women of American Horror Story , Karen J. Renner. |
| Graphic Novel |
| Neil Gaiman's Snow, Glass, Apples , Neil Gaiman & Colleen Doran. |
| F | Bone Parish Vol. 2 , Cullen Bunn, Jonah Scharf & Alex Guimarães. |
| F | Calcutta Horror , Alessandro Manzetti, Stefano Cardoselli & Poppy Z. Brite. |
| F | H. P. Lovecraft's At the Mountains of Madness, The First Volume , Gou Tanabe. |
| F | Monstress, Volume 4: The Chosen [Monstress, volumen cuatro. Las elegidas] , Marjorie Liu; Sana Takeda (il). |
| Poetry Collection |
| The Place of Broken Things , Linda D. Addison & Alessandro Manzetti. |
| F | Choking Back the Devil , Donna Lynch. |
| F | Dragonfly and Other Songs of Mourning , Michelle Scalise. |
| F | Mary Shelley Makes a Monster , Octavia Cade. |
| F | The Apocalyptic Mannequin , Stephanie M. Wytovich. |
| F | The Demeter Diaries , Marge Simon & Bryan D. Dietrich. |
| Screenplay |
| Us [Nosotros] , Jordan Peele (wr) (dr). |
| F | Doctor Sleep , Mike Flanagan. |
| F | Stranger Things: The Battle of Starcourt . |
| F | The Lighthouse , Robert Eggers & Max Eggers. |
| F | Midsommar , Ari Aster. |