| 2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 | 2002 | 2001 | 2000 |
| Novel |
| In the Night Room [La cámara oscura] , Peter Straub. |
| F | The Dark Tower VII: The Dark Tower [La torre oscura VII. La torre oscura] , Stephen King. |
| F | Deep in the Darkness , Michael Laimo. |
| F | The Wind Caller , P(atricia). D. Cacek. |
| Long Fiction |
| The Turtle Boy , Kealan Patrick Burke. |
| F | Dead Man's Hand , Tim Lebbon. |
| F | Lisey and the Madman , Stephen King. |
| F | Northwest Passage , Barbara Roden. |
| F | Zora and the Zombie [Zora y la zombie] , Andy Duncan. |
| Short Fiction |
| Nimitseahpah , Nancy Etchemendy. |
| Anthology |
| The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Seventeenth Annual Collection , Ellen Datlow, Kelly Link & Gavin J. Grant, eds.. |
| F | Acquainted with the Night , Barbara Roden & Christopher Roden, eds.. |
| F | The Many Faces of Van Helsing , Jeanne Cavelos, ed.. |
| F | Shivers III , Richard Chizmar, ed.. |
| F | Quietly Now: A Tribute To Charles L. Grant , Kealan Patrick Burke, ed.. |
| Collection |
| Fearful Symmetries , Thomas F. Monteleone. |
| F | 100 Jolts: Shockingly Short Stories , Michael Arnzen. |
| F | Demonized , Christopher Fowler. |
| F | Fears Unnamed , Tim Lebbon. |
| F | The Machinery of Night , Douglas Clegg. |
| First Novel |
| Covenant , John Everson. |
| Stained , Lee Thomas. |
| F | Black Fire , James Kidman. |
| F | Move Under Ground , Nick Mamatas. |
| Work for Young Readers |
| Abarat: Days of Magic, Nights of War [Abarat: Días de magia, noches de guerra] , Clive Barker. |
| Oddest Yet , Steve Burt. |
| F | Robot Santa: The Further Adventures of Santa's Twin , Dean R. Koontz. |
| F | Witch Season: Fall , Jeff Mariotte. |
| Non Fiction |
| Hellnotes , Judi Rohrig. |
| Illustrated Narrative |
| Heaven's Devils , Jai Nitz. |
| F | Lost Loves , James Lowder. |
| F | Aleister Arcane , Steve Niles (wr) & Breehn Burns (il). |
| F | Graphic Classics: Robert Louis Stevenson , Tom Pomplun, ed.. |
| Alternative Forms |
| The Devil's Wine , Tom Piccirilli, ed.. |
| F | ChiZine , Brett Savory, ed.. |
| F | Flesh & Blood Magazine , Jack Fisher, ed.. |
| F | The Goreletter (email newsletter) , Michael A. Arnzen. |
| Poetry Collection |
| The Women at the Funeral , Corrine de Winter. |
| F | The Desert , Charlee Jacob. |
| F | Men Are From Hell, Women Are From The Galaxy Of Death , Mark McLaughlin. |
| F | Waiting My Turn to Go Under the Knife , Tom Piccirilli. |
| Screenplay |
| Shaun Of The Dead [Zombies Party (Una noche... de muerte)] , Edgar Wright (dr) (wr); Simon Pegg (wr). |
| Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind [¡Olvídate de mí!] , Michael Gondry (dr) (st); Charlie Kaufman (sc) (st) ; Pierre Bismuth (st). |
| F | Hellboy [Hellboy] , Guillermo del Toro (dr) (sc) (st); Peter Briggs (st). |
| F | Dawn of the Dead , James E. Gunn. |
| Lifetime Achievement |
