| 2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 | 2002 | 2001 | 2000 |
| Novel |
| The Night Class [Clase Nocturna] , Tom Piccirilli. |
| Long Fiction |
| El día de los muertos , Brian A. Hopkins. |
| My Work Is Not Yet Done , Thomas Ligotti. |
| F | Coraline [Coraline] , Neil Gaiman. |
| F | The Origin , David B. Silva. |
| F | Cape Wrath , Paul Finch. |
| Short Fiction |
| The MiSFit Child Grows Fat on Despair , Tom Piccirilli. |
| F | Details , China Miéville. |
| F | Disappearances , Mort Castle. |
| F | The Green Man , Christopher Fowler. |
| F | The Plague Species , Charlee Jacob. |
| Anthology |
| The Darker Side: Generations of Horror , John Pelan, ed.. |
| F | The Year's Best Fantasy & Horror: Fifteenth Annual Collection , Ellen Datlow & Terri Windling, eds.. |
| F | Children of Cthulhu , John Pelan & Benjamin Adams, eds.. |
| F | Shivers , Richard Chizmar, ed.. |
| F | The Mammoth Book of Best New Horror: Volume Thirteen , Stephen Jones, ed.. |
| Collection |
| One More for the Road [Algo más que el equipaje] , Ray Bradbury. |
| F | Everything's Eventual [Todo es eventual] , Stephen King. |
| F | The Collection , Bentley Little. |
| F | Knuckles and Tales , Nancy A. Collins. |
| F | Nations of the Living, Nations of the Dead , Mort Castle. |
| First Novel |
| The Lovely Bones , Alice Sebold. |
| F | Atmosphere , Michael Laimo. |
| F | The Blues Ain't Nothing' , Tina Jens. |
| F | The Red Church [La iglesia roja] , Scott Nicholson. |
| Work for Young Readers |
| Coraline [Coraline] , Neil Gaiman. |
| F | Abarat [Abarat] , Clive Barker. |
| F | Abu and the 7 Marvels , Richard Matheson & William Stout. |
| F | Cat in Glass and Other Tales of the Unnatural , Nancy Etchemendy. |
| Non Fiction |
| Ramsey Campbell, Probably: Essays on Horror and Sundry Fantasies , Ramsey Campbell. |
| F | Ralan.com [2002] , Ralan Conley, ed.. |
| F | Supernatural Fiction Writers: Contemporary Fantasy and Horror, Second Edition (Volumes I & II) , Richard Bleiler, ed.. |
| Illustrated Narrative |
| Nightside (Issues 1-4) , Robert Weinberg. |
| F | Howard the Duck (Issues 1-6) , Steve Gerber. |
| F | Fort: Prophet of the Unexplained (Issues 1-4) , Peter Lenkov. |
| Alternative Forms |
| Imagination Box (multimedia CD) , Melanie Tem & Steve Rasnic Tem. |
| F | Flesh & Blood Magazine , Jack Fisher, ed.. |
| F | Jim in Egypt audio script based on the Mort Castle story) , Mort Castle. |
| F | The Tree Is My Hat (audio script based on the Gene Wolfe story) , Larry Santoro. |
| Poetry Collection |
| The Gossamer Eye , Mark McLaughlinn, Rain Graves & David Niall Wilson, eds.. |
| F | Guises (poetry section "Night Unmasked") , Charlee Jacob. |
| F | Night Smoke , Bruce Boston & Marge Simon. |
| F | This Cape Is Red Because I've Been Bleeding , Tom Piccirilli. |
| Screenplay |
| Frailty [Escalofrío] , Bill Paxton (dr); Brent Hanley (wr). |
| F | The Ring [La señal] , Gore Verbinski (dr); Ehren Kruger (sc) 2002, Hiroshi Takahashi (sc) 1998. |
| F | Minority Report [Minority Report] , Steven Spielberg (dr); Scott Frank & Jon Cohen (sc). |
| F | Signs , M. Night Shyamalan. |
| Lifetime Achievement |