| 1999 | 1998 | 1997 | 1996 | 1995 | 1994 | 1993 | 1992 | 1991 | 1990 |
| Novel |
| Children of the Dusk , Janet Berliner & George Guthridge. |
| F | Earthquake Weather , Tim Powers. |
| F | The Church of Dead Girls , Stephen Dobyns. |
| F | My Soul to Keep , Tananarive Due. |
| Long Fiction / Novelette |
| The Big Blow , Joe R. Lansdale. |
| F | Coppola's Dracula , Kim Newman. |
| F | Everything's Eventual [Todo es eventual] , Stephen King. |
| F | The Word , Ramsey Campbell. |
| F | The Zombies of Madison County , Douglas E. Winter. |
| Short Story |
| Rat Food , Edo van Belkom & David Nickle. |
| F | I Am Infinite, I Contain Multitudes , Douglas Clegg. |
| F | Madame Babylon , Brian Hodge. |
| F | A Plague on Both Your Houses , Scott Edelman. |
| Collection |
| Exorcisms and Ecstasies , Karl Edward Wagner. |
| F | The Throne of Bones , Brian McNaughton. |
| F | Painted in Blood , Lucy Taylor. |
| F | Things Left Behind , Gary A. Braunbeck. |
| First Novel |
| Lives of the Monster Dogs , Kirsten Bakis. |
| F | The Art of Arrow Cutting , Stephen Dedman. |
| F | Drawn to the Grave , Mary Ann Mitchell. |
| F | Hungry Eyes , Barry Hoffman. |
| F | The Inquisitor , Mary Murrey. |
| Non Fiction |
| Dark Thoughts: On Writing , Stanley Wiater. |
| F | The Encyclopedia of Fantasy , John Clute & John Grant, eds.. |
| F | Clive Barker's A-Z of Horror , Stephen Jones, ed.. |
| F | Dean Koontz: A Writer's Biography , Katherine Ramsland. |
| F | The Hammer Story , Marcus Hearn & Alan Barnes. |
| F | Video Watchdog , Tim Lucas, ed.. |
| Lifetime Achievement |
