| 2020 | 2019 | 2018 | 2017 | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 |
| Novel |
| The Book of X , Sarah Rose Etter. |
| F | Curious Toys , Elizabeth Hand. |
| F | Goodnight Stranger , Miciah Bay Gault. |
| F | Ninth House , Leigh Bardugo. |
| F | Nothing to See Here , Kevin Wilson. |
| F | Tinfoil Butterfly , Rachel Eve Moulton. |
| Novella |
| Ormeshadow , Priya Sharma. |
| F | Into Bones Like Oil , Kaaron Warren. |
| F | Late Returns , Joe Hill. |
| F | The Monster of Elendhaven , Jennifer Giesbrecht. |
| F | This Is How You Lose the Time War , Amal El-Mohtar & Max Gladstone. |
| Novelette |
| Luminous Body , Brooke Warra. |
| F | Black Bequeathments , Simon Strantzas. |
| F | Deeper, Darker Things , Steve Dillon. |
| F | Pwdre Ser , Kurt Fawver. |
| F | Taproot , M. R. Carey. |
| F | The Couvade , Joanna Koch. |
| Short Fiction |
| Kali_Na , Indrapramit Das. |
| F | How to Become a Witch-Queen , Theodora Goss. |
| F | The Truth About Josh Enloe , Nick Straatmann. |
| F | The Well , Mariana Enríquez. |
| F | Whistle, My Lad, and I Will Come , Gina Ochsner. |
| Collection |
| Song for the Unraveling of the World , Brian Evenson. |
| F | Collision: Stories , J. S. Breukelaar. |
| F | Every Human Love: Stories , Joanna Pearson. |
| F | Homesick , Nino Cipri. |
| F | Pájaros en la boca , Samanta Schweblin. |
| F | Wounds: Six Stories from the Border of Hell , Nathan Ballingrud. |
| Anthology |
| The Twisted Book of Shadows , Christopher Golden & James A. Moore, eds.. |
| F | Echoes: The Saga Anthology of Ghost Stories , Ellen Datlow, ed.. |
| F | The Mythic Dream , Dominik Parisien & Navah Wolfe, eds.. |
| F | The Unquiet Dreamer: A Tribute to Harlan Ellison , Preston Grassmann, ed.. |
| F | Wonderland: An Anthology of Works Inspired by Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland , Marie O'Regan & Paul Kane, eds.. |